Your Favorite Piano Methods, and our Next Topic!

Thanks for all your votes on this week’s poll! Here are the results:

Other responses were:
Music Tree
Alfred’s Premiere Piano Course

I love seeing the results of these polls – they are so interesting! I think it’s safe to say that a lot of piano teachers really love the Faber & Faber series. I am one of them. However, I am now excited to look into some of the methods that I have never used before, such as Music Tree. There really are so many wonderful piano methods out there! There really is so much more we could go into on this topic – but for now…

…onto our next topic:

Teaching Beginning Technique

I am really excited about this topic…this is where it starts getting fun! We know that teaching correct technique right from the beginning is so important…so how do we do this in such a way to help our students internalize and remember the concepts, make them habit, and have fun in the process?

We’d love to hear your great ideas on how to teach technique to beginners. What fun games do you use? How do you teach your students correct technique? What technique exercises do you use with your beginners? We’re looking forward to a great week!

Also, don’t forget to enter our GIVEAWAY!! You have until this Saturday at 11:59 pm. Click here to learn how to enter!

Personality Types & Piano Methods

Practical Piano Pedagogy
I just read a great chapter in Dr. Martha Baker-Jordan’s Practical Piano Pedagogy all about piano methods. In this chapter she has wonderful, in-depth reviews of ten different piano methods, focusing on Reading, Rhythm, Technique and Theory for each method. The ten methods she reviews are:

Bastien Piano Basics
The Music Tree
Faber & Faber Piano Adventures
Beanstalks Basics for Piano
Hal Leonard Student Piano Library
The Robert Pace Keyboard Approach
Alfred’s Basic Piano Library
John W. Schaum Piano Course
John Thompson’s Modern Course for the Piano
Piano Discoveries


I am excited to learn about some of these methods that I am unfamiliar with! Her reviews are so helpful. I also love how she has a section on “Methods and Character Types.” She says,

 “You can’t force the student to fit the program – you’ve got to make the program to fit the student.”

I completely agree with this. Although we may have our favorite piano methods, they may not work equally well for each individual student. Each student you teach has their own personality type, their own strengths and weaknesses. Each student learns in different ways (not to mention that each teacher teaches in different ways!).

Baker-Jordan discusses four different character types: Idealist/Dolphin, Guardian/Bear, Rational/Owl and Artisan/Ape. She includes charts for the most common two character types of piano teachers/students which illustrate the types of approaches, methods, materials and components that are most effective for that character type, as well as which specific piano methods are most effective.

I wanted to share this because it is so interesting, and so helpful! I definitely recommend this book; I am about halfway through it and so far it has been really helpful!

Don’t forget to enter our GIVEAWAY!! You can enter until this Saturday, April 17 at 11:59 pm. Click here to learn how to enter!

Piano Methods for Beginners

Ah, method books. I sure do have fond memories of my own – when I was learning to play the piano I used the John W. Schaum Piano Course:

John W. Schaum Piano Course Leading to Mastery of the Instrument "F" Brown BookJohn W. Schaum Piano Course Leading to the Mastery of the Instrument, D the Orange Book

and the Eckstein Piano Course:

Eckstein: Piano Course, Book 1Eckstein: Piano Course, Book 2Eckstein Piano Course, Book 3Eckstein Piano Course, Book 6

Seriously, good times. And let me tell you, whenever I come across these old books (which seem like old friends in a way!) at my parents’ house, I flip through the old yellowing pages and those great black and white drawings bring back lots of memories. Songs like “Bicycle Bill,” “Riding On a Mule,” “At the Junior Prom” (my FIRST-ever piece with the pedal – boy was I excited!) just pop right back into my head, and I really remember the joy and excitement I felt while learning to play the piano!

Although there is, of course, a place in my heart for these old black-and-white books I learned from, the method books these days are (thankfully) a lot more interesting and fun to look at (thanks in large part to the color illustrations!). I think that is so wonderful, because they have the potential to keep many students much more interested and excited about the piano.

Choosing a good piano method to use for a student is important. I think that a good method can and should do the following:

  • Help motivate the student to practice, and help keep the student interested (particularly when their books are fun and colorful and have fun pieces!)
  • Help them become musically-literate (especially when the method is well-rounded and includes things such as theory, ear training, transposition, music history, technique, etc.)
Having said that, I do believe that the success of the student depends much more on the teacher than on the method book used. I always have people ask me, “What method do you use?” I do not use one particular method on every student. 
For one thing, each student is unique and has different strengths and weaknesses. While I have common standards and a similar curriculum for each student in my studio, I tailor my teaching style to the individual student. One method book may work wonderfully for one student, but may be too advanced and fast-moving for another. 
If you are a good enough teacher and know how to teach correct technique, then you can probably make any method book work. However, there are so many wonderful methods out there that will be a big help in producing well-rounded musicians and music lovers!
Here are some basic things to consider when choosing a method book:
  • Which reading approach is used? Middle C, multi-key, intervallic, or a combination?
  • Does it use a good sequence of concepts? Is it comprehensive (includes technique, sight reading, ear training, etc.)?
  • Does it include all the essential theory concepts, such as intervals, chords, harmony, transposition?
  • Does it make sense to the student?
  • How is it designed/formatted – is it fun and colorful?
  • What kind of supplementary materials are included?  Does it come with supporting technology, such as CD’s?
In conclusion, I would evaluate some method books and decide which one fits best with your student’s strengths and weaknesses, as well as with your teaching style and studio curriculum. Hopefully the one you choose will someday become a dear old “friend” to your student, and will remind them of the joy they felt when they were learning from you how to play the piano!

__________________________________________________________________________

There are still a couple more days to vote on this week’s poll about your favorite method book. So far Faber & Faber’s Piano Adventures is definitely in the lead! We would love to have some comments about what your favorite method is, and something that you love about it – why would you vote for it as your favorite?

Piano Adventures: Lesson Book Primer Level (Piano Adventures Library)Alfred's Basic Piano Library: Lesson Book Level 1AWP200 - Bastien Piano Basics: Piano Primer Level (Primer Level, Wp200)Piano Lessons Book 3 - Book/CD Pack Edition: Hal Leonard Student Piano Library (Hal Leonard Student Piano Library (Songbooks))Lesson and Musicianship 2A: A Comprehensive Piano Method (Celebrate Piano!®)Premier Piano Course Theory 2a (Alfred's Premier Piano Course)The Music Tree: Student's Book, Part 1Piano Town: Primer Level LessonsMusic for Little Mozarts: Music Lesson Book 4

Visit our Helpful Resources page for links to some fabulous articles and charts about methods. I particularly like the article about evaluating new method books, found on ClavierCompanion.com in the September/October 2009 issue.

And don’t forget to enter our GIVEAWAY!! You can enter until this Saturday, April 17 at 11:59 pm. Click here to learn how to enter!

Giveaway, oh giveaway…

Time for our first ever *giveaway* on The Teaching Studio! We’d like to thank all our readers for reading our blog and leaving such great comments!

We will be giving one lucky reader a copy of “A Winter Concert” – a wonderful little book about a mouse who goes to a piano concert and experiences the joy of music. I really love this book, and I think you will too! We featured this book in a previous post on The Teaching Studio. We think it is adorable and would be a great book to share with your students!

HERE’S HOW TO ENTER!

  • Just leave us a comment on this post & tell us something you love about teaching music!

You can also submit extra entries by doing the following:

That’s right, up to THREE entries per person! **Make SURE you leave an additional comment for each of the above items, to let us know that you did them!**
You can enter until Saturday, April 17 at 11:59 pm. The winner will be randomly selected and announced on Monday the 19th. Blog creators (aka Janina and I) are not eligible to enter the giveaway, but contributors are!

First Lesson Poll Results & our new topic

Another week come and gone – I hope you all had a wonderful Easter weekend, and I hope that some of you are enjoying nice, warm spring weather (because here in Utah it is spring one minute, and a crazy winter blizzard the next!!)

Thanks to all who participated in our poll this week – I think it’s safe to say that nobody feels completely confident when they teach their very first lesson (and about a third of us felt completely clueless!), so you beginning teachers out there, take comfort! And if you are just starting out, be sure to check out this week’s posts on Teaching a First Lesson for some inspiration and ideas. Now to the poll results:

When I taught my VERY first lesson, I was:

Our topic for this next week will be:

Method Books & Repertoire for Beginning Students

Holy cow, what a huge topic! But what an important topic. We are going to need a lot of comments and input on this one. We would LOVE to compile some sort of chart or list of different method books for beginners/elementary students, and the pros and cons of each – it would be an awesome resource for all of us. It will probably be an ongoing project. So, in light of that, here is what we’d like to hear from you:

  • What piano methods do you use for your students, or what methods do you like?
  • Tell us some pros & cons of that method. Some ideas of things to mention:
    • reading approach (middle C vs. multi-key vs. intervallic)
    • theory that is included
    • skills included (such as ear training, transposition, harmonization, form, composition, improvisation, etc.)
    • quality of repertoire
    • included technology (such as listening CD’s)
    • overall look & quality of series
  • What type of student would you assign it to? For example, I would give this method to a student who is 6-8 years old, who has a pretty good attention span and is a great practicer, but plays too much by ear.
Also, don’t forget to take our weekly poll! Can’t wait to hear from you!

Piano Teaching Q&A: Piano Teaching Mama

Each week we will be featuring questions asked by our readers, and will do our best to answer them and to give some ideas 🙂 

One thing that came up the other day while at lunch with some piano friends was the question of whether it works to teach your own children piano lessons. It is an interesting subject, so I thought I’d open it up to our readers!

As a mom who is a piano teacher, this topic has come to my mind quite often, as I am sure it has for many of you readers who are also parents. It is quite the debate in my mind:

On the one hand, I have put in so many hundreds and thousands of hours in my own piano study and have achieved a college degree in piano performance, and I have taught for so many years and gained much experience – why not use all of this education and experience to bless my own family? Since my husband and I are both pianists, and both of our families are full of musicians, chances are that our kids will be quite musical. Think of all the money we could save on piano lessons! Think of the ease in scheduling lessons, the avoided hassle of finding the right teachers and driving children to all those lessons (not to mention the saved time that would be spent driving to all these lessons!), week after week after week. Think about how hard it really could be to find a teacher who I really feel could give my children a wonderful music education, when I, myself, have all the training and requirements I’d be looking for!

But on the other hand, what if my children just don’t respond to me in the role of piano teacher? What if it’s hard to separate between the two roles? What if, by taking lessons from their mother, my children are missing out on a wonderful teacher who could be an amazing mentor in their life? What if we get lazy and put off lessons, and thus lack the structure of normal piano lessons?

So much to think about. I really haven’t come to a conclusion yet. I may not be able to figure it out until my son is older. I do think that a lot of it may have to do with the personality of the child. For example, I used to teach my little sister and little brother. My sister responded fine to my teaching. My brother, on the other hand, would sit on the piano bench with his hands covering his ears, refusing to listen to me (thanks Josh!). (Luckily they both moved on to other teachers and both turned into fine pianists!) 

One of my former piano teachers once told me about teaching her own children. She actually had them walk out the front door and walk around to the studio entrance for their lessons. Once they walked in that door, she was their teacher. After the lesson they would walk back outside and into the front door, where she would greet them as their mother.

Ok, readers: what do you think? Any readers out there who currently are teaching their own children? Any who have children taking from someone else? Ready, discuss!

If you have a question you’d like to ask us, leave it in a comment or submit it here.

What to teach at a first lesson?

I absolutely loved Bonnie’s post on teaching a first lesson. There are so many wonderful things she said; I particularly love how she emphasized making it fun and exciting, and about nurturing the wonder of music in the student’s mind.

Yes, this is a huge and varied topic, depending completely on the personality, age, skill level, experience level and attention span of each student. Here are a few of my thoughts, to add to Bonnie’s, on the topic of teaching a first lesson:

  • Be friendly, be excited. Make it fun. I really cannot add anything to what has already been said on this topic.
  • Get to know the student. Find out what they want to get out of piano lessons. Do they want to study music in college? Do they want to be able to play the piano at church? Do they want to just be able to sit down at the piano and sight read? Sometimes you will be pleasantly surprised by the goals of your students; when your teaching is aligned with their goals it makes for a much more successful and positive experience.
  • Get on the same page. Each student is unique; no two students will be at the exact same starting point. If they are a transfer student, it may take a little while to assess exactly which level the student is at in their technique, theory, etc. Even some beginners will already know concepts that other beginners don’t. You may have to review some concepts with them or backtrack to make sure they have learned things correctly. This is actually a great thing to try and figure out before the first lesson, at a new student interview/audition, because it can take awhile.

Now let’s pretend your new student is a six- or seven-year-old beginner who has not had previous piano lessons. Here is a sample list of concepts to go over in the first lesson, and a few ideas on how to teach them. I like to make sure we cover technique, theory and repertoire in each lesson. Keep in mind that every student is different. Sometimes you will not have enough time to go over everything on this list; sometimes you will get through it in ten minutes! So be prepared but be flexible. And obviously you want to get through this information, but do it in a fun and interesting way! Put your own personality into it.

  • Technique
    • How to Sit at the Piano
    • Correct Hand Position
      • Stress from the very beginning that fingers should be nice and curved. Tell them to pretend their hand is a bird’s nest, then turn it upside down. I find this analogy works better than the holding a ball analogy (you don’t want the fingers too curved in!). Their fingers should be curved but relaxed – so as not to crack the eggs in the little nest! 
      • Put little dot stickers on the tips of the student’s fingers where they should be touching the keys, and also on the keyboard in a sort of half-circle shape (where their fingers should be touching), and have them match up the stickers! I used this method with a five-year-old boy once, and he loved it! I think it sometimes helps them to visualize it better.
      • Playing a five-note scale on C is great to start out with
  • Theory
    • Basic Layout of Keyboard (White/Black Notes, Black Note Patterns, High/Low Notes, etc.)
      • Make some sort of game out of it – it could be as simple as, “can you play all of the sets of 2 black keys?” or “can you play a set of 3 low black keys?”
    • Names of the White Keys
      • Make it fun – tell them a story! Here’s one I heard in a pedagogy class: the 3 black keys are Grandma’s house. Who lives in Grandma’s house? Grandma (G), of course! And what does she bake? An apple (A) pie! Grandma’s house has a front (F) door and a back (B) door. Outside there is a dog house (the 2 black keys), where Doggie D lives. Outside the doghouse there is also a cat (C) and an elephant (E). Don’t ask my why there is an elephant in Grandma’s yard – but if you have a better idea that starts with an E, I’d love to hear it! 🙂 Hey, at least an elephant is memorable, right?
      • Make it a game – play a white key and have them name the note as fast as they can. Name a note and have them play that note as fast as they can.
    • Basic Rhythm – quarter & half notes
      • I would love to know how you readers teach rhythm. There are so many methods of counting for beginners: “1-2-3-4,” “1-2, 1, 1” (counting out the number of beats for each individual note), “long, short short,” “half-note, quarter quarter” (I never really understood this method, because it takes twice as long to say “quarter” as it does to say “half” or “note”). 
  • Repertoire
    • It is nice for the student to be able to play something after their first lesson – whether it is a simple piece learned by rote, or the first piece in their method book
So there you have it, some ideas to get you started! Now tell me – what do YOU do at a first lesson? What concepts do you feel are important to go over? What things do you do to make it fun and exciting?

The First Lesson

There is never enough time in the first lesson. Think about all the things you would like to say and do. You could go on for hours! How do you get enough information into that little head to get them excited about music, motivated to work hard, and able to have a successful first practice week?

It’s kind of a huge subject to tackle, because no two students are exactly alike in personality, learning style, background, or previously-acquired knowledge and skills. Maybe you have a 5-year old who has never had a music class, an 8-year old who has played the violin for 4 years, a teenager who has had years of piano lessons but stumbles through reading simple pieces (oh, that one hurts my heart), or an adult who nervously admits to always having wanted to play, but fearing it is too late to learn.

So, rather than specifically outlining exactly what you “should” say or teach in the first lesson, I’d like to give some broad guidelines. Whatever you do, remember that you don’t have to do it all in the first lesson. Keep it simple, keep it fun, and be yourself.

  • Make the student comfortable.
    • Get to know them a little before diving into the subject matter. Even though there is a lot to cover, remember that this is the beginning of a (hopefully) long and important relationship. They need to know you are interested in them as a person, as well as a musician.
    • Make sure they know they can ask questions at any time.
    • If you’re anything like me, you (the teacher!) might be a little shy when getting to know a new student. Let them know that it will take a little while for the two of you to get to know each other. And don’t be afraid to let your personality show.
    • Tell the student a little about yourself, including things unrelated to music. Give them something they can identify with.

  • Give the student some structure.
    • Explain how your lessons will flow.
    • Explain how their assignment book is structured.
    • Explain what they are expected to do at home each day.
    • Talk about the shared responsibilities of the student, parent, and teacher.

  • Get the student excited.
    • Do something fun! Young children especially have eagerly looked forward to this day, filled with the wonder of music that is so evident to their little minds. Be careful to nurture that wonder, rather than squashing it with lengthy explanations and assignments.
    • Get off the bench. Move to the music. Do not for a moment let this newly opened mind begin to believe that music is boring and unmoving.

  • Give the student confidence.
    • Teach them something right in the lesson that they can master and take home with them. For a younger student, it might be as simple as naming 3 notes on the keyboard. An older student might be able to learn a simple piece by ear.
    • Explain very clearly what you want them to practice at home, and how to practice it. Give them enough to do that they will make some progress, but not so much that they will be overwhelmed.

I haven’t talked about what technique, theory, or literature to cover in the first lesson. Those things differ so completely based on the student’s age and experience that I hardly know where to begin. But you will know what to do, and if you don’t, you’ll make it up until you do. We all do that as teachers; the key is to do it with confidence!

Piano Friends

Today a fun group of my piano friends got together for lunch. We caught up, we talked about life, about teaching, and about juggling teaching and family. It was so wonderful to spend some time with these girls with whom I have piano teaching in common, and to bounce ideas off of each other. I miss seeing them on a regular basis on campus and in the practice rooms (it seems oh-so-long ago!), and after chatting with them I feel inspired to be a better teacher.

That is what I love about this blog and what I hope it will become – a place where we can all talk about teaching, where we can give each other ideas and encouragement, and where we can have a whole network of other teachers and piano friends to bounce ideas off of – because we all need some inspiration and support every once in awhile, right?

So thank you for reading, and thank you for all the wonderful comments! I am looking forward to more ideas about teaching a first lesson this week, as well as to our first giveaway! Stay tuned!

teaching how to teach

Some of you will remember my post about one of my dear piano teachers, in which I mentioned that she emphatically stated at our first meeting, “I teach teachers.” I love that.

It is because of her dedication and love for teaching that I became a teacher. And it was also because of her help and constant encouragement. She actually found my very first student for me (her next-door neighbor). She encouraged me and gave me advice. But one of the most helpful things that she did was this: one week, instead of my regular lesson, she taught me a lesson on how to teach a first lesson.

Looking back on this, I think this was one of the best things she could have done for me. Teaching a first lesson can be nerve-wracking, especially if and when you don’t have a clue what you are doing. It was so helpful to have her sit down with me and go over exactly what you should do on a first lesson.

I have had the privilege of teaching one of my own students a lesson on how to teach a first lesson. By this time I had quite a bit of experience to draw from, including pedagogy classes in college, but I still used quite a bit of the same material that my teacher taught me that day. It was actually a really cool feeling to encourage one of my own students to teach, just as my teacher had encouraged me. I would highly recommend encouraging some of your students to teach by teaching them how to teach a first lesson – after all, sometimes we just need a little push in the right direction!

What or who encouraged you to begin teaching? Did you have any help in learning what to do at the first lesson?

Don’t forget to take this week’s poll – and you can actually vote for more than one answer this week!

1 2
Verified by ExactMetrics